Bookstall Clash escalates on Kolkata’s College Street as SFI and ABVP supporters confront each other over rival bookstalls, triggering scuffles, police intervention and fresh political tensions.
Qalam Times News Network
Kolkata, November 18, 2026
Rival Bookstalls Turn College Street into a Battleground Between Left and Right-Wing Student Organisations
Bookstall Clash between members of the Students’ Federation of India (SFI) and the Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad (ABVP) turned Kolkata’s historic College Street area into a scene of tension on Wednesday morning. What began as a three-day bookstall initiative organised by the Left student organisation in front of the Mahabodhi Society has developed into a confrontation between two student groups with sharply contrasting political and ideological positions.

The situation escalated when ABVP members attempted to establish a separate bookstall directly opposite or in front of the SFI stall, seeking to promote nationalist literature as a counter to the progressive and Left-oriented publications displayed by their rivals. The competing attempts to occupy the same public space soon resulted in heated exchanges, physical altercations and police intervention. The Bookstall Clash also raised questions about freedom of expression, the use of public spaces and the growing political contest between student organisations in one of Kolkata’s most historically significant intellectual centres.
A Three-Day Mini Book Fair Triggers Dispute
The controversy began on Tuesday when the Communist Party of India (Marxist), primarily through its student wing SFI, launched a three-day ‘Mini Book Fair’ initiative near the Mahabodhi Society on College Street. According to the organisers, the programme had been arranged after obtaining police permission. The objective was to promote progressive literature, Left political thought and books associated with social and political movements. However, SFI members alleged that police personnel subsequently obstructed their efforts to operate the bookstall. Unable to continue the arrangement as originally planned, the students placed books along the tram tracks on College Street.
Police reportedly objected to the use of the tram tracks and attempted to remove the books, arguing that the arrangement violated regulations governing the public road. This led to confrontations between the student activists and police personnel, keeping the College Street area tense for much of Tuesday.
The dispute, however, took a new turn on Wednesday when ABVP members arrived with their own collection of books and attempted to establish a rival stall in the same area.
ABVP Brings Nationalist Literature as SFI Objects
Wednesday’s confrontation began when ABVP members sought to display nationalist publications alongside the SFI bookstall. Carrying books by Swami Vivekananda and images of Bharat Mata, ABVP activists staged a demonstration and demanded that they too be allowed to organise their bookstall. The move immediately intensified tensions between the two organisations. SFI members alleged that ABVP activists tore their banners and threw books by Karl Marx and Vladimir Lenin onto the road. These allegations became a major point of contention between the rival groups. The confrontation quickly developed into physical pushing and shoving, forcing police personnel to intervene. Both organisations appeared determined to assert their right to use the location for their respective literary and ideological activities.
Police Barricades Fail to Immediately Restore Normalcy

As the situation deteriorated, a substantial police force was deployed to College Street. Police personnel erected barricades and placed guardrails around the disputed area in an attempt to separate the two groups and prevent further confrontation. However, the intervention did not immediately restore calm. ABVP members attempted to break through the police barricades, resulting in further pushing and scuffling with security personnel. During the confrontation, an SFI member reportedly sustained injuries and fell to the ground. He was quickly rescued and taken away from the immediate scene. Meanwhile, ABVP activists continued their protest, with some lying on the road to demand permission to operate their own bookstall. Their principal demand was that if SFI was permitted to display its publications, ABVP should also be allowed to organise a similar activity.
College Street Becomes the Centre of an Ideological Contest
The incident has brought competing political and ideological traditions into direct confrontation on College Street, an area widely associated with Kolkata’s intellectual, literary and student culture. The dispute is no longer limited to the physical space occupied by two bookstalls. It reflects a broader disagreement over the right of student organisations to promote their respective political philosophies and literature in public spaces. SFI sought to showcase progressive and Left-oriented publications, while ABVP attempted to counter this initiative with nationalist literature and symbols. Both organisations have sought to establish their presence in the area through competing cultural and political activities. However, the physical confrontation has overshadowed the original purpose of the programmes: encouraging reading, discussion and the exchange of ideas.
The incident also raises an important question about how authorities balance the right to peaceful political and cultural expression with regulations governing public roads, tram tracks and pedestrian movement.
A Question of Equal Opportunity and Public Order
The dispute has placed the police administration in a difficult position. If one organisation receives permission to conduct a book-related programme, questions naturally arise about the criteria governing similar applications from other groups. At the same time, permission to organise a public event does not automatically grant any organisation the right to occupy tram tracks, obstruct traffic or disregard public-safety regulations. The authorities must clarify the conditions under which the original SFI programme was permitted, why objections were subsequently raised and whether ABVP’s request for a separate bookstall was formally considered. The administration must also ensure that neither organisation is subjected to arbitrary restrictions or allowed to use confrontation to impose its presence on others.
College Street Needs Books, Not Street Confrontations
College Street has long represented the intellectual character of Kolkata. Its bookstores, publishing houses, educational institutions and historic literary traditions have made it an important destination for students, readers, researchers and writers. The competing bookstall initiatives could have provided an opportunity for people to encounter different political philosophies and literary traditions. Instead, the confrontation has shifted public attention from books to banners, barricades and physical clashes. Whether the dispute continues or is resolved through negotiations, both organisations must recognise that ideological differences should be expressed through literature, debate and peaceful public engagement rather than physical confrontation. The police administration, meanwhile, must ensure that public spaces remain accessible and that all organisations are treated according to transparent and consistent rules.
College Street should remain a place where ideas compete through books and arguments—not where students have to fight over the right to display them.
